So This Is Why W Reunioned at the White House

Bookmark and Share

It’s 11:35pm on a Tuesday night. I’m sitting on a train, the Amtrak Lake Shore Limited, on my way to Chicago. I boarded the train in a Rochester rain at 11:25pm, twenty-five minutes later than the schedule dictated. It didn’t matter. I’m not in a hurry. I haven’t been in a hurry since the sun first rose.

Yes, my lackadaisical day began in surprising sunshine. I say “surprising” because I happened to be in New Haven, Connecticut. In another era, it would have been raining. I would have also taken the train straight from the Elm City to Chicago. As it was, I had my 14-year old son with me and Chicago was not on his pre-approved college visit itinerary. Rather than make him truant, I drove the lazy expressway for six hours from New Haven to Rochester. Upon arriving in the suburban paradise called Mendon on the outskirts of the Flower (née Flour) City at 4:00pm, I unloaded my son and excess Yale baggage, wrote and filed two assignments, processed a couple shareholder transactions and quickly packed for my conference. My wife chauffeured me to the train station in the soulless heart of downtown Rochester a half-hour before my listed departure. I waited for nearly an hour.

I wasn’t in a hurry.

I wasn’t in a hurry because I knew I’d be writing this, a story of disappointment. That story begins months before today and culminates in a surreal conversation with a nice lady at the Rose Alumni House yesterday when most of the east coast normally eats lunch.

I woke up late that morning. Say around 10:00am. I wasn’t in a hurry. My son slept through my morning ritual of watching my fingers dance in front of the flat LCD screen of my portable office. By 10:30am I told my still sleeping offspring I was going downstairs to get breakfast. He mumbled his order and rolled over back to sleep. He wasn’t in a hurry.

Back home, no one was in a hurry, either. A freakish late April snowstorm had closed the area schools. It turned out his pre-approved day off needn’t have been. Like his hometown friends, he and I slept in. Hmm, maybe he more than me. It was all well and good. Our meetings weren’t booked until after lunch. I did, however, intend to make an unscheduled stop at the AYA office in Rose Hall for the purposes of carrying out a mission requested of me by several classmates.

You see, this year marks the thirtieth anniversary since we seceded from Yale. We actually held a secession party in the spring of our senior year, but that’s another story. Come to think of it, maybe it’s not. That particular event in April of 1982 turned out to be our last “official” Cottage party. It featured, as one might expect, mass quantities of adult beverages and pizza. As one might not expect, it also featured a relay race involving a triathlon of questionable juxtaposition, namely, running, chugging certain pre-specified adult beverages and swallowing said pizza whole. In truth, the “swallowing whole” leg was not part of the official rules. It was merely the natural outcome of mixing the stated rule of “eat the pizza as fast as you can” with the normal amount of competitive testosterone that (at least) once lingered vibrantly in the courtyard of Davenport.

Ah, Davenport.

That party, held at no cost due to some fortuitous connections I had made through the radio station with the local Budweiser distributor and the then new Domino’s pizza franchise, had its fill of controversy. In all, it remains one of the greatest singular events sponsored by the Cottage’s infamous inhabitants, known only by the ever-undefined initials “CTO.”

Ah, the Cottage.

Such are the memories that continue to satiate the minds of those who participated both in person and by proxy. It wasn’t that we were Delta House, although that’s what many insisted the “D” etched in the entryway arch signified. No, it was that we had the uniquely American spirit of that fictional fraternity, albeit with a dash more of self-responsibility (emphasis on the word “dash”). That one of us was and is Canadian only indicates that portion of the American spirit to which I refer. Over the years, as John Ford would have appreciated, the legend of the Cottage and the CTO grew larger than the fact. (And, again as Ford’s editor in “The Man Who Shot Liberty Valence” would have approved of, I printed that legend on a regular basis in a series of now-misplaced missives titled: The CTO Chronicles.)

So it is that this, our thirtieth reunion, is slated to occur within the hallowed Georgian walls of Davenport College. It was only natural for the members of the CTO to inquire as to the availability of the Cottage for lodging during the reunion. Calls were made. Emails were sent. Yet we received no official response. It was then I offered to meet with whoever I needed to at AYA to secure the Cottage, or at least get a plausible reason for the denial.

Monday morning saw no rain on the streets of New Haven. Well, at least that tiny portion of the tail end of Monday morning when my son and I finally ventured out of the dry confines of our hotel room. We walked unannounced into Rose to find the usual musty smell of age and eerily empty offices. It was as though aliens had stolen away all of mankind. Though barely past noon when you’d expect the staff to be lunching, it seemed odd they didn’t post at least one token carbon life form to remove any reason for suspicion.

Tucked away in a labyrinth of halls, we finally found a human who immediately shuttled us off to the correct person. What follows is a summary account of that incredible conversation. Some may laugh. Some may be offended. I merely report the proceedings.

The woman (whose name I will not reveal in hopes of preventing any mindless acts of revenge), surfaced from the masonry basement stairwell with a smile and a mouth not quite finished chewing whatever it was she was eating. I apologized for interrupting her meal and told her of my mission.

“The Cottage?” she asked, somewhat surprised. “Why, weren’t you told? That’s not made available for lodging. We use it for storage during the summer.”

There. That was simple. But I didn’t expect the next bit of dialog.

“Why must it be the Cottage?” she asked.

Alas, the boys had said they’d consider attending the reunion, but only if we could get the Cottage. I knew her answer doomed me to yet another reunion seated at a lonely table with only an itinerant squirrel to keep me company. But, don’t feel too bad. Team CTO has its own annual reunion at an undisclosed location, and it will occur again this year. But not in May. And not in New Haven. Yes. This did all race through my mind as I answered, “Well, several of our roommates were waiting to decide on whether to attend the reunion. If we could get the Cottage, they’d come. If not, then they’d pass.”

That went over like a lead balloon. The woman’s eyes said “How dare they!” Her mouth said, “How many people did you want to room together? Davenport has been remodeled and there might be suitable alternatives.”

I told her I expected five.

This time a look of suspicion crossed her face and, in a way that said she already knew the answer, she tentatively asked, “Will they be coming with their wives?”

I said, simply, “No.”

Wrong answer.

She then spoke the most unbelievable series of words my innocent ears could have heard. It was as though all the press clippings on the CTO were true. (I know as a matter of fact they weren’t, considering I wrote most of them.) She started, “This is why we don’t encourage alums to stay in their former rooms. They have a tendency to forget who they are and return to their youthful exuberance. They can get a little reckless.”

All I could muster was, “Well, let’s get serious here. The definition of “reckless” changes with age. We’re all over 50 now and, heck, most of us can’t stay up past 11pm.” I said that with a straight face, knowing full well I was up to 4am that very morning putting the finishing edits into my book. What she said next knocked me out.

“You’d think that,” she reeled me in. “But we’ve had guys on their 60th reunion trash the place.”

Sixtieth reunion? Do you know how old that is? That’s early 80’s. And they’re having wild parties?!

To my CTO roommates and the brothers and sisters who, with us, share the undying spirit of the Cottage, let me just say one thing and make it perfectly clear:

We now have a new goal in life.

Let the squirrels rejoice.


  1. jeffrey irish says

    as a once regular cottage guest with a
    permanent seat at the spades, hearts
    and bridge table, i enjoyed reading your
    piece chris.

Speak Your Mind